Riot Games vs Valve Software
Posted by Hwa Soo "MeaNy-" Cho 1 year ago
Not so long after Valve Software has filed a trademark for DotA, Riot Games has made a response.Riot Games is the game production company that has created League of Legends, a game that resembles DotA. Valve Software, too, is developing another DotA game that many believe would be the most successful successor to the original DotA as Icefrog, the current DotA mapmaker is involved in the Valve's DotA project.
Valve has recently filed a trademark for "DotA". Three days after, on August 9th, Riot has counter-filed a trademark for "Defense of the Ancients", the unabbreviated name of DotA. According to Riot Games' Steve "Pendragon" Mescon, Riot has "filed for the 'Defense of the Ancients' trademark to protect the work that dozens of authors have done to create the game and on behalf of the millions of DotA players all over the world". Furthermore, Pendragon has stated in an interview with PC Gamers that DotA belongs to the original creators, Guinsoo and Eul, without mentioning Icefrog.
Riot Games' ultimate wish is to let DotA or Defense of the Ancients be contributed to the community. However, how would they explain their irony in filing a trademark for Defense of the Ancients themselves? Furthermore, who exactly has the right to decide the ownership of DotA? Who has more power over it? Hopefully, more of these questions may be answered in the future.
To read the full interview between Pendragon and PC Gamers, visit the source listed below.
| Links |
| PCGamer.com - source |
| Comments \ Paging |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
|
| old story is old but still, some people only rely to gg.net for news so thumbs up for gg.net |
| weeeeeeee |
| Valve made CS Riot Games made LoL nuff said. |
| It's all IceFrog's, duh.. |
| lol |
| fu pendragon we want dota 2 riot r just moneyhungry hoes who dont want their gme to collapse cuz thats what gonna happen when dota2 is out |
| valve FTW!! |
| #4 +1 |
| screw you pendragon c'mon guinsoo gave up on dota, icefrog is the one who make dota as big as now |
| To be frank, it feels very backwards for Riot to claim the DotA and try to develop the game. I am very convinced that the best for all DotA lovers and the community is if Valve/Icefrog makes the next DotA release. I can't understand why Riot can't see this, they are clearly in it for money only. |
| Amen to you guys. Riot Games is very desperate to stop this recreation of DotA. Pendragon et al just have to wish them the best and let it be. |
| If the community spreads we should be happy. Noobs satisfied with shit or constantly pubowned in DotA will go to riot, rest to valve. GG no re. Besides dota without icefrog or someone who has as much sense of balance and gameplay will not survive the next versions. |
| so ridiculous that they didn't even mention icefrog as the developer of dota, without him there wouldn't be any league of legends either. riot games is a bunch of faggots... |
| ALL-IN for Icefrog and Valve |
| fckin nerd.."on behalf of the millions of DotA players all over the world" y right...u make a cheap ripoff,try to defame the current mapmaker aka god and countless other cheap tricks to demote dota and promote the ripoff.. and now u think u hv a right to speak for the community.... .i. |
| even if riot games won the rights for the name "DOTA" We all know that icefrog= DOTA right so go valve... poor euls and guinsoo but the fact that they stop updating DOTA for sometime makes Icefrog the owner of DotA(for me cause he was really serious on improving the game). Now euls and guinsoo going after what they left zzzz what a bitch Icefrog Improved your game to the point that it is now the most coveted game and now u came back because Dota now is famous... gtfo |
| i just dont give a fuck xD...idiots fighting over it, when we all know that icefrog is the god, he created dota the way it is today, nobody else...he made it so popular, they need to bow in front of him, not act like idiots.. |
| come on, come on, icefrog and the original crators of this game deserve to earn lot of money from it. enought said. I would be glad to see icefrog and hes staff getting good money from all that work. these guys invented a new kind of game. i bet all my minerals on icefrog+valve, I WILL BUY THE GAME WHERE HE IS WORKING WITH CLOSED EYES. |
| #10 +1 It's Icefrog's map, he made it to what it is. He credits Eul and Guinsoo with the original idea and stuff, but all the balancing and the mayority of the heroes and gameplay tweaks comes from Icefrog and his beta tester teams. Valve offered Icefrog their teams to further develop an engine around the original dota and stuff just to improve on it even more and create "Dota 2". Which is the most awesome idea ever! LoL was a joke and Riot is a joke company, in NL we call them fast boys. Fast boys are just in it for the money, thinking of short term sceme's to create a bulk of money and hopping from 1 sceme to the other without any real form of substainable marketing. Just *sigh* at their statement ._. it can't be more shallow. . . |
| lol WITHOUT ICEFROG , THERES no DOTA. Pendragon cant see this because he's blinded by the income he gets from riot. |
| Icefrog = DOTA. |
| I also love how Pendragon claims to be fighting Icefrog and Valve for the sake of the DotA Community. LOL! He shut down the community's old forum and turned what's left of it into a massive advertizement for his cartoonish LoL. Gimmie a break, man. |
| how is them trademarking defense of the ancients good for the community etc. ? what a bunch of morons |
| This is just low ... what a bs, credits to Guinso and Eul but u cant claim dota now that icefrog has taken it so far for such a long time. Riot are desperate .. |
| No IceFrog no DotA , nuff said |
| their game describes their entire company perfectly, 'LoL' |
| Icefrog owns DotA so noob like Guinsoo should just shut up. |
| They want to sue someone for something they haven't supported for years? I can't even remember when Guinsoo and the other egghead left the development of DotA, it's been IceFrog only since like waay back. |
| for those who hate what riot games has done, you can spam their inbox or site by going to http://www.riotgames.com/contact or a direct email to media@riotgames.com have fun cos i know i will =D |
| And yet again... Money screws everything up. |
| DotA = IceFrog [2] |
| #29..<3 u...im on it |
| Pendragon crawl back to the hole you came from |
| I know for a fact that Pendragon just wants Icefroge to have a hard time making a trademark for this game because of their falling apart about 2 years ago or so. For me, Pendragon should've allowed Valve to trademark this game. Trademarking DotA is one of those milestones that everyone in our Dota community hopes to achieve. TL;DR FU PENDRAGON! FOR WHINING BECAUSE THERE WOULD BE ANOTHER DECREASE IN PLAYER POPULATION FOR LOL WHEN DOTA 2 RELEASES! |
| Petty move. They better work on their marketing strategy. |
| #29 +1 gogogo spam them! |
| money for them .. damn so selfish ppl .. for their opwn sake .. DotA will crush u all .. |
| I personally think it's disgusting the way Riot says that they have the right to claim the game. Guinsoo fucking QUIT developing DotA god knows how many years ago when it was getting nowhere. ICEFROG was the guy who fucking MADE what DotA is now; the fun and exciting game it is. Back in Guinsoo's time, there were fucking SAs with death wards and perma invi at level 1, and other imbalanced shits like void demon. Everything was fucked up. Icefrog pulled together all that and basically pioneered the competitive scene. And now, when he's trying to get some well-deserved income through developing this game with Valve, guess what? The fucking sheepstick and his pet dragon come and claim it. Well that's just absurd. P.S.: That homo dragon didn't even develop shit, he was just the webmaster. P.P.S.: I vote for a guinsoo nerf 6.69 |
| #29 Nice one, I'm gonna abuse this so much :D |
| If you want to make a move for the DotA community here is what yo can do for me: gtfo, we are perfectly fine with what IceFrog does to the game. |
| Damn only 3 E-Mails per hour, gonna use the other one then :P |
| fuck you pendragon,i guess you should just change your nickname to penis than a pendragon fucker |
| #38, 40. nuff said |
| We want valve, FO riot |
| #38 ROFL at the P.P.S. |
| # 41...lul..:D..i alrdy sent 1 hint- my subject of the mail was... .i. suk it |
| hah, #47 got owned badly :D 10 E-Mails should be enough for now. |
Advertisement
Latest news
Feb 10
Feb 10
Feb 9
Feb 9
Feb 8
Feb 7
Feb 7
Feb 5
Feb 3
Feb 1
Trust
vs.
SkyNet
7h46m
MYM
vs.
StarsBoba
7h46m
Velocy
vs.
Invasion Red
7h47m
Aeon
vs.
Neolution
7h47m
G7
vs.
XctN
7h47m
Mineski Inf..
vs.
iDeal
7h48m
eNcy
vs.
Orange
7h48m
RedSpade
vs.
Izone
7h48m
Orange
vs.
Neolution
10h+
Latest from the forums
Tyloo 2012
(0)
Poll
Which team is most likely to pull a surprise upset in this weekend's GEST? (58 votes)
XctN | (29%) |
||
SkyNet | (25%) |
||
Velocy | (18%) |
||
G7 | (6%) |
||
iDeal | (6%) |
||
iZone 125 | (5%) |
||
RedSpade | (3%) |
||
eNcy | (3%) |
||
Most recent blogs
Feb 9
xboctfanboy: KICKED
(26)
Feb 8
TheMak3R: Windrunner play!
(00)
Feb 7
marCoon: GamesCom 2010 Memories 1
(01)
Feb 6
valio: Android app i made
(00)
Feb 5
Esc4toN: Kingdoms of Amalur
(02)
Feb 4
Pianoparanoia: Pub Commentary #1
(00)
Feb 3
Hastebreak: Deceiving Work Life
(07)
Feb 2
iii.: new Divide
(04)
Feb 2
MoonlightEverest: My Euro Travel
(08)
Jan 31
Pride+: Pendulum The Island Remix
(00)
Top GosuBetters
| #1 |
|
| » neu.wetpaks.com |
| #2 |
|
| » IlyarKoooo |
| #3 |
|
| » PiRoJoK777 |
| #4 |
|
| » BabyF4CE |
| #5 |
|
| » markbb0319 |
| #6 |
|
| » MakeSomeSense |
| #7 |
|
| » rolancsa17 |
| #8 |
|
| » ExiLe-- |
| #9 |
|
| » nYkz |
| #10 |
|
| » wara_ka |
» View all










Search
3
You are not a logged in, or you are not registered. Create an account or login to be able to post a comment.
SGC
ngy














